Saturday, November 05, 2005

Holyrood Abbey Church, Edinburgh (C of S)

When visited:

23rd October, 2005, 11am and 6:30pm


To the NE of central Edinburgh, just near Sainsbury's


People shaking hands on door, some members of the congregation spoke to me, generally welcoming but not in-your-face. Good.

First Impressions:

I guess about 150 people there morning and evening, with a wide range of ages.

Type of Service:

The services were done almost entirely by the minister from the central pulpit (the only exception being a children's slot in the morning service, for which he came down to the front). Apart from the singing, the minister was speaking almost all the time.


Piano, well played in traditional bar-type style (though I guess they'd not like me calling it that). Hymns were mostly "golden oldies", well sung.


Both showed good understanding of and work on the passage. The morning one (on Jesus' encounter with Zacchaeus from Luke 19) was excellent. I disagreed with some of the exegesis in the evening one (on 1 Corinthians 11:2-16), but can't think of a much better explanation of a very difficult passage. Both could have been made even better by more clear and challenging application.


yes, pretty good


Doctrinally solidly evangelical/reformed, traditional Presbyterian. I get the feeling they maybe recognise the need for change in the long term, but find it difficult because they've got very good at doing what they do.

No comments: